Song Styles

Custom Anniversary Song: How to Choose the Style

Choose the sound of a custom anniversary song: which genre fits which couple, the era from the year you met, the voice, and one verse only you could own.

By Seb, founder of Only Happy Tears5 min read

In this article
  1. Your last anniversary already picked the genre
  2. Set the era from the year you met
  3. Name the song that was playing back then
  4. Decide which voice is singing to whom
  5. One verse only the two of you could claim
  6. Bring the sound, the year and your four lines
  7. Frequently Asked Questions

An anniversary song has one listener, and that listener already knows every fact in it. The worry is that it will sound like any couple's, and that the wrong sound will make your own story feel borrowed.

To choose the style of a custom anniversary song, look at how the two of you celebrate. Acoustic suits a quiet couple, R&B a slow-dance couple, Country the ones with a truck and a town in their story, and Jazz couples past 30 years. Set the era from the year you met, then choose the voice.

A long-married couple in their sixties slow-dancing in socks in their kitchen on a weekend morning, a crossword and coffee mugs on the table behind them

Your last anniversary already picked the genre

Forget the number of years for a moment. The way you spent the last one says more about the sound you need, and you don't have to explain it to anyone.

Takeout on the couch, phones off: Acoustic. One guitar or a piano and a voice, at an unhurried pace. Quiet couples tend to distrust big gestures, and this sound doesn't make any. Feed it one small scene: the night he drove back for the soup you forgot, the crossword you split down the middle. If your kind of quiet ends with the two of you laughing until the neighbors knock, Pop will suit you better.

Furniture pushed back, music on: R&B. Round bass, warm keys, a slow groove and a voice that curls around the line. This is for couples who still dance when nobody asked them to, at a cousin's wedding or in the garage. It wants physical memory: whose feet get stepped on, the hip she bumps you with on her way past. If neither of you has danced since the wedding, Acoustic will be more honest.

A drive past the old house: Country. Acoustic and steel guitar, a two-step drum and verses that move forward through time. Country suits a story with a truck and a town in it: the pickup with the bench seat, the feed store where she worked, the water tower you both swear you climbed. Road names sing well here. If it's a town you were both glad to leave, the genre will get misty about the wrong thing, so try Rock and let the song be about getting out.

The same table, dressed up, decades in: Jazz. Brushed drums, upright bass, piano and a horn, at an easy swing. Past 30 years, a couple has stopped needing to prove anything, and Jazz has the dry, amused tone for that. Give it the wit: the thermostat argument now entering its fourth decade, what she says every time he orders the fish. The years alone aren't a reason, though. If neither of you has ever put on a jazz record, go with the music you do play.

If your marriage has faith at the center and you'd both want that said out loud, Worship is the option to choose. If your two tastes never met, Songwriter's choice lets your story set the sound.

A woman in her sixties at her kitchen table laughing behind her hand, glasses in the other, as she hears a song on the phone on the table, her husband leaning in beside her

Listen to an anniversary song

An example song. Yours is written from your story.

Set the era from the year you met

The quiz offers the 60s, 70s, 80s, 90s, 2000s, 2010s, 2020s and Timeless. Take the year you met and pick its decade. The era changes the arrangement around the same words: R&B from the 70s leans on a live band with strings and horns, from the 90s on programmed drums and stacked harmonies, from the 2010s on something sparer and darker.

A few cases the simple rule doesn't settle:

  • You met at the very end of a decade. Go with the decade of your first full year together. If you met in November 1989 and everything you remember happened after New Year's, pick the 90s.
  • You met before 1960. The earliest option is the 60s. Choose it, or choose Timeless.
  • You knew each other for years first. Use the year it turned into something, not the year you were introduced.
  • You found each other later in life. You may have met in the 2010s and still own every record from the 70s. Pick the one you'd both put on tonight.

Name the song that was playing back then

Most couples have one: the slow one at the reception, the song on the radio in the parking lot, the CD stuck in her car for an entire summer. It's one of the best details you can give us, as a detail. Write it into your memories the way you'd tell it:

The jukebox at Lou's was stuck on [song title] the night we met, and we kept feeding it quarters so we'd have a reason to stay.

Your song can mention that title in a passing line, and only the two of you will know why. It won't quote that song's words or borrow its melody, and it won't be made to sound like whoever recorded it. What you get is a new song that remembers the old one.

Decide which voice is singing to whom

The quiz gives you a female voice, a male voice, or either. Your own voice isn't an option, so treat this as casting.

  • Match your own if you want it to land like a letter from you. They'll hear the song as you speaking to them.
  • Pick the one they turn up in the car if your partner has always had a favorite kind of voice. A gift to their ears is still a gift.
  • Choose either if the words are what you care about and you'd rather the voice follow the song.

One verse only the two of you could claim

A line like "we've been through so much" is true of every couple who ever stayed. Here's a test for your answers: put your neighbors' names on each memory. Anything that's still true of them gets cut. Then fill in these four, which are enough for a whole verse:

  1. A place with its real name. The apartment over the dry cleaner on Fifth, where every shirt you owned smelled like starch.
  2. A sentence one of you always says. "Did you lock the back door," asked after you're both already in bed.
  3. A disagreement you'll never settle. Who was driving the night you got lost in Vermont.
  4. Something you've noticed that they don't know you've noticed. He turns the radio down before he parks, every single time.

Those four could not belong to anyone else. Save the last one for the end of the song.

Bring the sound, the year and your four lines

Choose who it's for, pick Anniversary as the occasion and start your anniversary song. It takes about three minutes, and we write their song from your answers. You can also read what a song from Only Happy Tears includes.

It arrives as a private gift they open like an envelope, and it's yours to download and keep forever.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the difference between a love song and an anniversary song?

A love song can be about how you feel right now. An anniversary song has a length of time behind it, so it can say what happened: the places you lived, the habits that formed, the promises that held. That gives it more to work with, and it's why a plain list of what you've done together often sings better than praise.

Should an anniversary song say how many years we've been together?

It's your choice, and each way has a cost. Naming the number makes the song belong to this anniversary, which is lovely if it's a big one. Leaving it out means you can play the song next year and it still fits. If you do name it, say in your answers whether you're counting from the day you met or the wedding.

How do I keep a custom anniversary song a surprise?

Answer the questions on your own phone when your partner is out of the room. Nothing ships, so there's no box to intercept, and the song stays with you until you send the gift link. If you need a detail you've forgotten, ask a friend who was there, or bring up the old days over dinner without saying why.

Is a custom song a good anniversary gift for a husband who isn't sentimental?

It can be, if you keep it to facts instead of feelings. Choose a genre he already plays and fill the song with things that happened: the truck that died on your honeymoon, the deck he built crooked, the team he makes you watch. A plain record of your life together can carry the feeling without anyone having to announce it.

What if my spouse and I like completely different music?

Pick for the one receiving it. The song is a gift to their ears, so if your wife plays Country and you play Rock, choose Country. If the two of you are ordering it together and neither will budge, Timeless as the era and Songwriter's choice as the genre let the story decide, so nobody loses the argument.

Seb, founder of Only Happy Tears

Music has carried all of us through the hard days and the happy ones. I started Only Happy Tears after writing a song for my family to tell them how grateful I am. Their first reaction was happy tears. Now I want everyone to be able to give that moment to the people they love, at a price anyone can afford and with no subscriptions.